A new chemical study of the hexane extract of the gorgonian Briareum polyanthes collected in Puerto Rico afforded 10 new diterpenes of the eunicellin class, briarellins 1-9 and polyanthellin A (10), along with the known diterpene briarellin D (11). The structures and relative stereochemistry of metabolites 1-10 were assigned on the basis of NMR studies, chemical methods, and comparisons to the spectral properties of 11. A reassessment of prior structural assignment for briarellin A and two known sclerophytin-type diterpenes, 13 and 14, is proposed. Antimalarial tests on 1-6 and 8-12 indicated that they were active against Plasmodium falciparum.