The synthesis of novel melatonin analogues 3a and 4a-c designed as melatonin receptor ligands is described. Among the newly synthesized ligands, 2-((S)-2-hydroxymethylindolin-1-ylmethyl)-melatonin 4b displayed the highest affinity for MT(1) receptors (K(i)=9.8 nM) and for MT(2) subtype (K(i)=7.8 nM), whereas the rigid pentacyclic ligand 3 showed the highest selectivity towards the MT(2) receptor subtype (K(i)=319.3 nM for MT(1) and K(i)=65.2 nM for MT(2)).