Twenty-seven natural product-like polyprenylated phenols and quinones were synthesized and their neuroprotective activity was tested using human monoamine oxidase B (MAO-B) and SH-SY5Y cells. Eight compounds inhibited MAO-B (IC<sub>50</sub> values < 25 μM) and the inhibition mode and molecular docking of two (8c and 16c) were investigated. Compounds inhibiting MAO-B activity were additionally tested for their ability to protect SH-SY5Y cells from peroxide injury. Three derivatives (3c, 8c and 16c) exhibited both MAO-B inhibitory and neuroprotective activity. A structure activity-relationship study showed that a phenolic hydroxyl group and a longer side chain are important for both activities.