Heteroarene-fused anthraquinone derivatives represent a class of perspective anticancer drug candidates capable of targeting multiple vital processes including drug resistance. Taking advantage of previously demonstrated potential of amide derivatives of heteroarene-fused anthraquinones, we herein dissected the role of the heterocyclic core in antitumor properties. A new series of naphtho[2,3-f]indole-3- and anthra[2,3-b]thiophene-3-carboxamides was synthesized via coupling the respective acids with cyclic diamines. New compounds demonstrated a submicromolar antiproliferative potency close to doxorubicin (Dox) against five tumor cell lines of various tissue origin. In contrast to Dox, the new compounds were similarly cytotoxic for HCT116 colon carcinoma cells (wild type p53) and their isogenic p53 knockout counterparts. Modification of the heterocyclic core changed the targeting properties: the best-in-series naphtho[2,3-f]indole-3-carboxamide 8 formed more affine complexes with DNA duplex than furan and thiophene analogs, a property that can be translated into a stronger inhibition of topoisomerase 1 mediated DNA unwinding. At tolerable doses the water soluble derivative 8 significantly inhibited tumor growth (up to 79%) and increased the lifespan (153%) of mice bearing P388 lymphoma transplants. Together with better solubility for parenteral administration and well tolerance by animals of the indole derivative 8 indicates prospects for further search of new antitumor drug candidates among the heteroarene-fused anthraquinones.