To develop novel antibiotics, targeting the early steps of cell wall peptidoglycan biosynthesis seems to be a promising strategy that is still underutilized. MurA, the first enzyme in this pathway, is targeted by the clinically used irreversible inhibitor fosfomycin. However, mutations in its binding site can cause bacterial resistance. We herein report a series of novel reversible pyrrolidinedione-based MurA inhibitors that equally inhibit wild type (WT) MurA and the fosfomycin-resistant MurA C115D mutant, showing an additive effect with fosfomycin for the inhibition of WT MurA. For the most potent inhibitor <b>46</b> (IC<sub>50</sub> = 4.5 μM), the mode of inhibition was analyzed using native mass spectrometry and protein NMR spectroscopy. The compound class was nontoxic against human cells and highly stable in human S9 fraction, human plasma, and bacterial cell lysate. Taken together, this novel compound class might be further developed toward antibiotic drug candidates that inhibit cell wall synthesis.