Synthetic efforts toward complex natural product (NP) scaffolds are useful ones, particularly those aimed at expanding their bioactive chemical space. Here, we utilised an orthogonal cheminformatics-based approach to predict the potential biological activities for a series of synthetic bis-indole alkaloids inspired by elusive sponge-derived NPs, echinosulfone A (1) and echinosulfonic acids A-D (2-5). Our work includes the first synthesis of desulfato-echinosulfonic acid C, an alpha-hydroxy bis(3 '-indolyl) alkaloid (17), and its full NMR characterisation. This synthesis provides corroborating evidence for the structure revision of echinosulfonic acids A-C. Additionally, we demonstrate a robust synthetic strategy toward a diverse range of alpha-methine bis(3 '-indolyl) acids and acetates (11-16) without the need for silica-based purification in either one or two steps. By integrating our synthetic library of bis-indoles with bioactivity data for 2048 marine indole alkaloids (reported up to the end of 2021), we analyzed their overlap with marine natural product chemical diversity. Notably, the C-6 dibrominated alpha-hydroxy bis(3 '-indolyl) and alpha-methine bis(3 '-indolyl) analogues (11, 14, and 17) were found to contain significant overlap with antibacterial C-6 dibrominated marine bis-indoles, guiding our biological evaluation. Validating the results of our cheminformatics analyses, the dibrominated alpha-methine bis(3 '-indolyl) alkaloids (11, 12, 14, and 15) were found to exhibit antibacterial activities against methicillin-sensitive and -resistant Staphylococcus aureus. Further, while investigating other synthetic approaches toward bis-indole alkaloids, 16 incorrectly assigned synthetic alpha-hydroxy bis(3 '-indolyl) alkaloids were identified. After careful analysis of their reported NMR data, and comparison with those obtained for the synthetic bis-indoles reported herein, all of the structures have been revised to alpha-methine bis(3 '-indolyl) alkaloids.