We recently presented a novel class of ABCG2 modulators based on the third-generation ABCB1 inhibitor tariquidar bearing a 2,5-linked tetrazole instead of an amid linker. We investigated the modulating potential of the compound class by enlarging the substitution pattern on the outer phenyl rings of the scaffold. To identify the structural conditions for achieving a high response, we decided to determine the individual influence of substituents on the scaffold using monosubstituted derivatives. While electron withdrawing groups (with a few exceptions) and bulky moieties decreased the modulating potency, small electron donating groups ensured a high activity level. Interestingly, the unsubstituted derivative 32 reached a similar inhibitory potential as the best derivatives in the previous study. Enzyme kinetic assays indicated that our derivatives have the same binding site as reference inhibitor Ko143. They were found to interact competitively and non-competitively with the substrates Hoechst 33342 and pheophorbide A, respectively.