DNA intercalating agents are a consolidated therapeutic option in the treatment of tumor diseases. Starting from previous findings in the antiproliferative efficacy of a series of indeno[1,2-c]cinnoline-11-one derivatives, we performed a suitable decoration of this scaffold by means of a simple and straightforward chemistry, aiming to a) enlarge the planar core to a pentacyclic benzo[h]indeno[1,2-c]cinnoline-13-one and b) introduce a basic head tethered through a simple polymethylene chain. In fluorescence melting and fluorescence intercalator displacement assays, these new compounds displayed fair to very good intercalating properties on different nucleic acid strands, with preference for G-quadruplex sequences. Inhibition of human topoisomerase IIα and antiproliferative assays on HeLa and MCF7 tumor cell lines outlined a multitarget antiproliferative profile for tetracyclic 6 and pentacyclic derivative 20, both bearing a N,N-dimethylamine as the protonatable moiety. Particularly, compound 6 displayed a very potent inhibition of tumor cell proliferation, while 20 returned the highest thermal stabilization in melting experiments. In summary, these results outlined a potential of such highly planar scaffolds for nucleic acid binding and antiproliferative effects.