(N)-Methanocarba ([3.1.0]bicyclohexyl) adenosines and corresponding ribosides were synthesized to identify novel A<sub>1</sub> adenosine receptor (A<sub>1</sub>AR) agonists for CNS or peripheral applications. Human and mouse AR binding was determined to assess the constrained ring system's A<sub>1</sub>AR compatibility. N<sup>6</sup>-Dicyclobutylmethyl ribose agonist (9, MRS7469, >2000-fold selective for A<sub>1</sub>AR) and known truncated N<sup>6</sup>-dicyclopropylmethyl methanocarba 7 (MRS5474) were drug-like. The pure diastereoisomer of known riboside 4 displayed high hA<sub>1</sub>AR selectivity. Methanocarba modification reduced A<sub>1</sub>AR selectivity of N<sup>6</sup>-dicyclopropylmethyl and endo-norbornyladenosines but increased ribavirin selectivity. Most analogues tested (ip) were inactive or weak in inducing mouse hypothermia, despite mA<sub>1</sub>AR full agonism and variable mA<sub>3</sub>AR efficacy, but strong hypothermia by 9 depended on A<sub>1</sub>AR, which reflects CNS activity (determined using A<sub>1</sub>AR or A<sub>3</sub>AR null mice). Conserved hA<sub>1</sub>AR interactions were preserved in modeling of 9 and methanocarba equivalent 24 (∼400-fold A<sub>1</sub>AR-selective). Thus, we identified, and characterized in vivo, ribose and methanocarba nucleosides, including with A<sub>1</sub>AR-enhancing N<sup>6</sup>-dicyclobutylmethyl-adenine and 1,2,4-triazole-3-carboxamide (40, MRS7451) nucleobases.